The jury statement for the Caligari film prize 2026 to IF PIGEONS TURNED TO GOLD
We saw the film we selected as the winner of the 2026 Caligari Prize quite early on in our viewing marathon, and it has stayed with us ever since. This is due to its theme, but also to its cinematic methods.
“Memory is an unreliable storyteller,” it says at one point. Memory is still unreliable, even though the archive of our personal records—photos, videos, audio recordings, texts, recorded by us or others—is growing infinitely, increasingly in the form of materials that no longer have a pictorial character.
Memory and archive remain two different things. All the more so when you can make photos of people say things they might never have said themselves. The use of AI in this film is extensive, but always alienated and always recognizable as such. The audiovisual breaks, and perhaps also the ethical wrongness of putting words in people's mouths, are never covered up by gloss. The reflective figure for this is a squeaking pigeon. A filter—perhaps also a mask—that turns all naturalism into its opposite.
The appropriation of the family archive by AI is undoubtedly questionable. At the same time, the film never claims to be ethically unassailable, and that is to its credit. The obviously alienated photos and voices contrast with actual documentary material, thus emphasizing this intrusive alienation of the intimate and almost sacred, unclouded images of childhood.
The video recordings show her brother in vulnerable situations, and the director asks herself to what extent someone suffering from addiction can actually give consent. She is torn between incapacitation and empowerment, between the impulse to protect her brother and the desire to allow him to act on his own behalf. The real material is juxtaposed with the unreal, and the two challenge each other. Even when AI-generated voices make seemingly factual statements, the “uncanny” aesthetic motivates doubts about their accuracy. Pepa admits to her own unreliability several times.
“If Pigeons Turned to Gold” is a film that questions itself and its narratives, full of moments of irritation. The theme is addiction, both her own and that of others, and its surmountability and structural conditionality. The focus is on substance addiction, but underlying this is the addiction to control over the narrative of the film and its voices, as well as over her brother's addictive behavior. This tension is explicitly addressed.
Through brutal directness, she attempts to overcome her own shame. The pop-like form, developed from YouTube formats, stands in stark contrast to the intimate confessions. The film's reflective process is equally accessible and difficult to digest.
The Caligari Prize for 2026 is awarded to “If Pigeons Turned to Gold.”